
Choosing among the best free AI writing tools is easier when you compare them the same way each time. This post walks through a simple method: shortlist a few tools, note their stated limits, features, price and data policy, then decide based on your own priorities.
When I first went looking for the best free AI writing tools, I had about nine browser tabs open and a headache to match. Every site said it was the best. Every pricing page looked a little different. After an hour, I couldn't remember which tool had which limit, and I gave up and made coffee instead.
What finally worked was boring but effective: a simple sheet. One row per tool, a few columns for the things I cared about, and nothing else. A sheet clears the clutter. It turns a fuzzy "which one feels better?" into something you can actually look at and compare.
Here's how to set up a comparison of AI writing tools, step by step, plus a few common pitfalls to avoid.
Short on time? Our top picks: ChatGPT, Claude, Google Gemini and Jasper. See all picks

This is the step most people skip, and it's why they get stuck. You don't need to try every writing AI tool out there. You need to compare the two or three that seem like a real fit.
How do you narrow it down? A good way to start is with tools recommended by people you trust, or ones that keep coming up when you search for the kind of writing you do. If you write product descriptions, a tool built for marketing copy, such as Jasper, might make the list. If you write long blog posts, you'd look for AI content writing tools that handle longer drafts.
More than three is overkill for a first pass. You can always swap one out later. Starting with five or six just recreates the tab chaos you were trying to escape.
Put each tool's name in the first column of your sheet. That's it for now.
Most AI writing software has some kind of free option. It might be a free plan, a trial, or a set number of words or credits. The trick is to copy what the tool's own page says, word for word if you can.
This one is easy to get wrong. It's easy to write "free trial" in your notes for a tool, then find out later the trial needed a card upfront and switched to paid automatically. If I'd copied the exact wording, I'd have caught that.
Things worth noting in this column:
Also write down the date you checked. Free limits change, sometimes quietly. A note like "checked March 3" saves you from trusting old info.
Notice I said to you. Feature lists on tool websites can go on forever, and most of it won't touch your daily work.
Before you look at any feature page, jot down what you actually need. For me, that list was pretty short:
Then make one column per need and just mark yes, no, or "sort of." The "sort of" column is often the most useful one, because it flags things you need to test yourself.
What's overrated, in my view? Huge template libraries. A tool might boast hundreds of templates, but I've only ever used a handful. A clean editor and good results from a plain prompt matter more to me than a long menu.
If you'd like some ready-made prompts to test each tool with the same input, my Free 25 Writing Prompts Starter Sheet is yours when you join the email list, and it makes side-by-side testing a lot fairer.
This is the part that makes a comparison real. Give each tool the exact same job. Test each tool with something you'd really write, like an intro for a post or a short email. Then I read the results back to back.
You'll notice things fast. One tool might sound stiff. Another, like ChatGPT or any similar assistant, might add facts you didn't ask for, which means you'd need to check everything it writes. Make a quick note in your sheet about how each one did.
Go to each tool's pricing page and copy the price the way it's shown. Don't round it, and don't guess what it'll be next month.
Pay attention to small details here. Is the price monthly or billed yearly? Is it per person or for a whole team? Some pages show a lower yearly price per month, which looks cheaper until you see you're paying for twelve months at once.
Keep two columns for this: "price as shown" and "what you'd actually pay." The second one is where you write things like "billed yearly" or "need the middle plan for the feature you want." That second column is often the eye-opener.
And if a price isn't listed, just write "not shown." Don't fill the gap with a number you found on some random forum.

This one gets skipped a lot, and I get why. Privacy pages are long and dry. But if you paste client work, private notes, or anything sensitive into a tool, you should know what happens to it.
You don't need to read every line. Look for a few plain things and write a short note for each tool:
Keep your notes brief, like "says it may use inputs, opt-out in settings." If something is unclear or the wording confuses you, it's fine to mark it "unclear" and ask the company directly. For anything involving client contracts or legal questions about data, check with someone qualified rather than relying on your own reading.
Now your sheet is full. This is where it pays off.
Before you pick, rank what matters most. Maybe price is the big one for you right now. Maybe it's the data policy because you handle client work. Maybe it's simply which tool gave the best draft in your test. Put your top priority first and look down that column.
Sometimes the answer jumps out. Other times two tools are close, and that's okay. When it's a tie, I go with the one I enjoyed using. If a tool annoys you during testing, you'll avoid opening it, and then it doesn't matter how good it is.
One more thing: you're not locked in forever. Switching tools is normal, and it can happen more than once. Keeping the sheet means switching later takes ten minutes instead of a whole afternoon.
If you'd rather not build the sheet from scratch, the AI Tool Comparison Table Template Kit below this post has the columns set up already. And if you want more background on what to look for before you even start, the AI Writing Tools Buyer's Guide and Comparison Sheets is down there too.
If you are not sure which tools to put in the first column, these are well-known names that many writers start with. Treat them as candidates to test, not final answers.
A general chat-style assistant that suits people who write many different kinds of things, from emails to blog drafts. Check what the free version includes today and which features sit behind a paid plan.
A conversational assistant that suits people who paste in longer notes or documents and want help shaping them. Check the free usage limits and the data settings before you paste anything sensitive.
A good fit if you already live in a Google account and want drafting help close to your other tools. Check which version you get for free and how your activity is stored.
Built with marketing teams in mind, so it suits people writing ads, product descriptions, and brand-style copy. Check whether a trial is offered and whether payment details are needed to start.
Suits marketers and small teams who want help with sales and promotional writing. Check the plan structure, especially whether pricing is per person or per team.
Best for people who already have a draft and want help with clarity, tone, and polish rather than writing from scratch. Check which editing features are free and which need a paid plan.
Suits bloggers and content creators who want help with longer articles and drafts. Check how limits are counted, such as words or credits, and what happens when you hit them.
Before you commit to any of these, check current plans and prices on each brand's own site.
Two or three is plenty for a first round. More than that gets confusing fast. You can always swap in a new one if your first picks don't work out.
Not always. Free plans or trials are often enough to test basic writing. Just note which features are locked, since the paid version may behave differently.
It helps to check your choice every few months or before you renew a plan. Prices and free limits can change without much notice. Adding the date you checked each detail helps a lot.
Go back to your top priority and see which one wins there. If it's still a tie, pick the one you enjoyed using more. Comfort matters, because you'll use it more often.
Pick two or three tools. Copy the free limits and prices exactly as shown. Note only the features you need, test each tool with the same task, and skim the data policy. Then choose based on what matters most to you.
Your next step is easy: grab the Free 25 Writing Prompts Starter Sheet from the sign-up box so you have the same prompts ready for testing. Then, if you want a head start on the sheet itself, take a look at the products below this post.
A printable guide and comparison sheets to note what matters to you before you look at any seller...
See detailsA tool that writes copy-and-paste comparison tables and deal boxes for your own review...
See details