← Blog

How to Fairly Test the Best AI Tools for Marketing

How to Fairly Test the Best AI Tools for Marketing

Choosing among the best AI tools for marketing is easier when you compare them the same way every time. This guide shows how to test two tools fairly, using one real task, one prompt, and a way of judging that you set before you see any results.

Many people compare the best AI tools for marketing the lazy way. A common mistake is to open one tool, type whatever comes to mind, then open the other and type something a little different. Then I'd pick the one that "felt" better. That's not a test. That's a coin flip with extra steps.

If you're paying for one of these tools, or about to, you deserve a better way to choose. The good news is that a fair test isn't hard. It mostly comes down to one rule: give both tools the same job, under the same conditions, and judge them the same way. Here's how I do it now.

Short on time? Our top picks: ChatGPT, Claude, Google Gemini and Microsoft Copilot. See all picks

How to Test Two Tools Fairly. The list includes Pick one task, Use the same prompt, Judge the result.

What you need

Step 1: Pick one real task

Start with something you'd do anyway. Skip fun tricks like "write a poem about a cat as a pirate." Pick the boring, real stuff. A product description you need to write, the kind of job AI tools for digital marketing like Jasper often get used for. An email to a client who's late paying. A summary of a long article for your newsletter.

Why real? Because a tool that's great at party tricks can still be clumsy with the work you do every Tuesday. You want to know how it handles your Tuesday.

Keep the task small enough to finish in one sitting. "Write my whole website" is too big. "Write the About page intro, around 150 words" is just right. Smaller tasks are easier to judge, and you'll actually finish the test instead of getting bored halfway.

Tip: If you can't decide, pick the task you dread most. That's usually where a good tool saves you the most time, so it's the best place to find out which one helps.

Free gift: get the Free 25 Writing Prompts Starter Sheet when you join our email list. Get it free

Step 2: Write one prompt to test two AI tools word for word

This is the step most people skip, and it's the one that matters most. Write your prompt once. Save it. Then paste the exact same text into both tools.

Don't retype it. Don't "improve" it for the second tool because you thought of a better phrase. Even small changes can shift the result a lot, and then you're not testing the tools anymore. You're testing two different prompts.

A good test prompt includes:

Here's a rough example: "Write a friendly but firm email to a client named Sam whose invoice is two weeks overdue. Keep it under 120 words. Mention the invoice number 1042. Don't sound angry."

Also try to start both in a fresh chat or new document. If one tool has a long history of your old chats and the other doesn't, that's not a level field. Same goes for any custom settings or saved instructions. Turn them off in both, or set them the same in both.

Tip: Paste the prompt into your notes file first, then copy from there into each tool. That way you've got a record, and you'll never wonder later what you actually typed.

Step 3: Decide how you'll judge before you see anything

Do this before you read the results. This is an easy lesson to learn the hard way. If you look first, you'll quietly build your rules around whichever answer you already like.

Write down three to five things that matter for this task. Keep them simple and specific. For that overdue email, mine might be:

  1. Did it include the invoice number correctly?
  2. Does it sound polite but clear about payment?
  3. Is it under 120 words?
  4. Would I send it with only light edits?

Then give each one a score. Use a 1 to 5 scale because it's quick. You don't need fancy math. You just need the same ruler for both tools.

Notice that "it sounds smart" isn't on my list. Plenty of AI writing sounds smart and says very little. Something plain that does the job is usually the better pick.

Tip: Accuracy belongs on almost every list. If a tool gets a name, number or fact wrong, that's a real problem, even if the rest reads beautifully. Always check facts yourself against your own records.

By the way, if you'd like some ready-made tasks to practice this on, the free 25 Writing Prompts Starter Sheet you get for joining the email list is handy for exactly this.

Step 4: Time how long it takes to get something usable

Start your timer when you paste the prompt. Stop it when you have a result you'd actually use. Not the first answer. The first usable answer.

This matters because the speed of the reply is almost never the real cost. Both tools might spit out text in a few seconds. But if one needs four follow-up messages before it gets the tone right, that's the time that counts.

Write down two numbers:

If you're on a free plan for one tool and a paid plan for the other, keep that in mind. Free tiers sometimes run slower or have limits, so a slow result might be the plan, not the tool. Check each seller's page for what their plans include.

Tip: Don't rush to "win." Work at your normal pace. You're trying to see what an ordinary workday with this tool looks like, not set a record.

How to Test Two Tools Fairly. A short list of 6 tips with a link to read more.

Step 5: Count the edits you had to make

Here's where the truth usually shows up. Take each final draft and look at what you had to change before it was ready.

Were you fixing a couple of words? Or rewriting whole sentences? Did you have to cut a cheesy opening line? (So many AI drafts start with something like "I hope this email finds you well," which I always delete.)

You can sort edits into rough buckets:

A tool that needs heavy edits every time isn't saving you much, even if it's fast. Honestly, this is where my opinion changes the most. A tool I thought was impressive at first glance often turns out to need more fixing than the plainer one.

Tip: Save the raw output before you edit it. Paste it into your notes, then make a copy to work on. Later, you can compare the raw versions side by side, and it's often eye-opening.

Step 6: Run each of the best AI tools for marketing more than once

One test is a start, but it's a small sample. AI tools can give different answers to the same prompt on different tries. One lucky or unlucky result can throw off your whole decision.

If you have time, run the same prompt two or three times in each tool, each in a fresh chat. Or better, repeat Steps 1 through 5 with a second, different real task. If one tool wins on both, you can trust that a lot more.

It's fine if you don't always do five rounds. Life's busy. But I try to do at least two tasks before I spend money on anything.

Tip: Mix your tasks a little. One writing task and one summary task will tell you more than two nearly identical emails.

Step 7: Write down your decision and why

Lay your notes side by side. Look at scores, time and edits for each tool. Then write one or two sentences about your choice. Something like: "Tool B wins for client emails. Faster to a usable draft and needed fewer edits. Tool A was better at long summaries, though."

That last part is common. Sometimes neither tool wins everything, and that's useful to know. You might decide one tool is worth paying for and the other is fine on its free plan for the odd job.

Writing it down sounds fussy, but it saves you from redoing this whole test in three months when you forget why you picked what you picked. If you like having a place for all of this, the Prompt Planner and Prompt Log Workbook below this post is built for keeping prompts and results together. A plain notebook works too.

Tip: Note the date and the plan you tested on. Tools change their features and pricing, so your results are a snapshot, not a forever answer.

Troubleshooting

Both results look about the same

That happens more than you'd think. Try a harder task, one with more steps or a trickier tone. If they still tie, pick based on things like price, ease of use or which one you simply enjoy opening. A tie is still an answer.

One tool refused or gave a weird answer

Run it again in a fresh chat. If it keeps happening, that's part of your result. A tool that often misreads normal requests will cost you time in real life too.

I can't stop favoring the one I already pay for

Totally human. Try hiding which is which. Paste both raw outputs into one document labeled "A" and "B," wait an hour, then score them. Or ask a friend to pick the better one without telling them which tool made it.

The results changed when I tried again a week later

Tools get updated, sometimes often. That's why dating your notes helps. If a big decision rides on it, rerun a quick test before you commit to a long plan.

If you're comparing several writing tools and want a structured way to line them up, the AI Writing Tools Buyer's Guide and Comparison Sheets below this post give you a format to fill in as you test.

AI tools worth putting through a fair test

If you're not sure which two tools to line up against each other, these are well-known options that suit the kind of everyday marketing tasks in this post. Pick two, give them the same prompt, and see what happens.

ChatGPT

A general-purpose chat assistant that suits people who want one tool for emails, summaries and drafts. Check which features come with the free plan versus a paid one before you compare it to something else.

Claude

A chat assistant from Anthropic that many people try for longer writing and summarizing jobs. Check the usage limits on your plan, since they can affect how many test rounds you can run.

Google Gemini

A good fit if you already live in Google's apps and want an assistant close to your documents and email. Check which Gemini features are included with your particular Google account.

Microsoft Copilot

Suits people who work in Microsoft's tools and want an assistant that sits alongside them. Check which version you'd actually get, as the free and work-account versions can differ.

Jasper

A writing tool aimed at marketing teams, with a focus on brand voice and campaign content. Check whether its setup and team features matter to you, or whether a general chat tool does the job.

Copy.ai

A marketing and sales writing tool that suits people who want a more guided, template-style experience. Check how it handles your own tone and facts by using the same test prompt you use elsewhere.

Writesonic

A content tool for blog posts, ads and product copy that suits small teams and solo marketers. Check the output length and editing tools on your plan, then count your edits as in Step 5.

Check current plans and prices on each brand's own site before you start your test.

FAQ

How many tools should I compare at once?

Two is the easiest. Once you add a third or fourth, it gets hard to keep track and the testing starts to feel like homework. If you have several options, compare two, keep the winner, then test it against the next one.

Is a free plan good enough for testing free AI marketing tools?

Often, yes, for getting a feel for a tool. Just know that free plans can have limits on speed, length or features, so results may differ from the paid version. Check the seller's page to see what each plan actually includes.

Should I tweak my prompt for each tool to get the best result?

Not during the fair test. Use the exact same prompt first, so you're comparing the tools and not your wording. Afterward, feel free to play around and see how much better each one gets with some tuning.

How long should a fair test take?

For one small task in two tools, around 30 to 60 minutes is typical for me, including notes. Running a second task adds a bit more. It's a small time cost compared to paying for the wrong tool for months.

Your next step

Pick one real task today and run it through both tools using the steps above. If you want a few ready-to-use tasks to practice with, grab the free 25 Writing Prompts Starter Sheet by joining the email list. Then, if you'd like a tidier way to track your tests of AI tools for coding, writing or anything else, take a look at the AI Writing Tools Buyer's Guide and Comparison Sheets and the Prompt Planner and Prompt Log Workbook below this post. Either way, you'll be choosing based on real results, not a hunch.

Free gift: get the Free 25 Writing Prompts Starter Sheet when you join our email list. Get it free
Tip: General information only. AI output can be wrong, so check facts yourself and read each tool's terms and privacy notes.

Printables and tools that can help

AI Writing Tools Buyer's Guide and Comparison Sheets

A printable guide and comparison sheets to note what matters to you before you look at any seller...

See details

Prompt Planner and Prompt Log Workbook

A printable workbook to plan prompts and log what...

See details